Blog Details

Movies With Mark > Reviews > Movies > Action > “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” Review

“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” Review

Director: Francis Lawrence Screenwriter: Billy Ray, Michael Lesslie Cast: Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Ben Wang, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace, Maya Hawke, Whitney Peak, Kelvin Harrison Jr. Distributor: Lionsgate Running Time: 158 min. MPAA: PG-13

The biggest problem with a prequel is knowing how it ends. This is why I kinda liked the previous Hunger Games prequel movie, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, as it focused on the original character, Lucy Gray. Sadly, there are no Lucy Grays in the follow-up prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping. This film centers on so many familiar characters from the original Hunger Games series of books and movies that you can’t help but notice the flaws in the similarities and the lack of tension about who will survive. And while it tries to recount past events believably, the script seems more concerned with keeping everything aligned than with telling a genuinely thrilling dystopian story that doesn’t feel routine.

At the center of the story is Haymitch Abernathy, who grows up to become a drunk veteran of the district battles to the death and ends up as a mentor. Having once been played by Woody Harrelson, the young Australian actor Joseph Zada tries to replicate the accent and mannerisms. The movie sets up his character to suffer a fall from grace based on what we know will happen to him. He starts the film by admitting that he doesn’t drink, but we know that will change. He has a love interest in Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), but they are so madly in love, with their constant kissing, that we know this won’t last and that something will tear them apart. He is forced into the Hunger Games, where young representatives from each district battle to the death, and he is guaranteed death for his insolence, but we know he’ll make it out alive. Naturally, we expect to see some exciting events that led him down the path to survival, disillusionment, and alcoholism. But as the story progresses, it becomes clear that Haymitch has little control over his actions, as more powerful forces shape his image, whether they want him to be a Hunger Games star or a future revolutionary.

Even after running well over two hours, a stale routine still plays out, leaving no room for the defining moments that would be most compelling. We watch as Haymitch befriends the other tributes of his district, including the feisty Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), the gambling Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), and the innocent youngster Louella McCoy (Molly McCann). Beyond those simple traits, though, there isn’t much time to get to know these players. Most of their dialogue focuses on game strategy or the Capitol’s corruption. The story follows the usual motions of games that have grown tiredly repetitive. If you’ve watched all the Hunger Games movies, you know the drill: the selection ceremony of the tributes who fight, the train ride, the training, the makeover, the parade, the televised interviews, the pre-game conspiring, and the inevitable countdown for the kids to kill each other on the battlefield. There are some small surprises here and there, but they add little to a story that can’t stop those old gears once they start grinding. They grind so loud that the rivals in this competition are reduced to cartoonish villains who love being strong and violent, killing less for their district and more for their own absurd satisfaction.

Repetition becomes one of the most aggressive sins of a movie like this. One would think that Haymitch would go through a fascinating transformation from being the chipper boy who doesn’t drink to the disillusioned man who doesn’t stop drinking. But the story settles on the perpetual scenes of Haymitch holding dying friends and associates in his arms. After the fourth scene of Haymitch losing somebody he cares about, I was expecting him to grow numb at some point, but the tears keep on coming as those around him are chopped down either through the games or the state. Just as repetitive as the identical tragedies is the first act’s never-ending cavalcade of cartoonish Capital residents. We get Glenn Close as the district escort, Drusilla Sickle, who looks like a garish doll in her loud outfits, with a stretched face and a short temper with anyone who insults her looks. Then we get Kieran Culkin playing up his role as the eccentric Caesar Flickerman, making a fuss over his makeup and getting all giddy as he plays to a crowd. Billy Porter plays Sickle’s husband, Magno Stift, a stylist with snakes for earrings who always makes a loud entrance. He has to compete with the other vibrant stylist, Effie Trinket, played by Elle Fanning, trying to match the perky ego of the character previously played by Elizabeth Banks. And then there’s the prep team duo of Proserpina and Vitus, who are, get this, also weirdly dressed and way too excited about these games. All of them cavort over District 12’s tributes in what feels like an exhausting circus of everybody competing in a Ruby Rhod contest. And if they’re all operating at the same volume and in the same hues, then nobody is Ruby Rhod.

The few capital characters that aren’t trying to gnaw on the gaudy scenery are less obnoxiously loud but not much better for being reduced to exposition-heavy dialogue. Ralph Fiennes drops his British accent to match Donald Sutherland’s performance as President Snow and always sounds off, serving up a stiff performance. One of the few actors who fits the part is Jesse Plemons as the media manipulator Plutarch Heavensbee, mostly because he doesn’t have to try as hard to match Philip Seymour Hoffman’s voice. Plemons gives the most natural performance as a crafty conspirator, and I wish the film didn’t treat him as a vessel to explain the obvious. His opening scene shows how he directs the tribute announcements to cover up the bloodshed and focus on the drama that draws in audiences. It’s a great moment, but the following scene sadly undermines it, as he has to explain to the young tributes how the government contorts what the audience will see and accept.

For a film that boasts some over-the-top spectacle in its design, there are so many exciting developments that seem to happen off-screen. The most exhilarating moment during the game is when a triggered natural disaster sweeps the battlefield, but every death from this spectacle is told rather than shown. There’s some danger in the conspiring forces that want to shut down the games, but we never get to see the government forces arresting key figures and torturing them, and it feels like we’re incredibly late for the interrogation. We still see some executions during the Hunger Games, but few carry emotional weight. It doesn’t help that seeing Ben Wang on screen reminded me of his role in The Long Walk, where every death in that dystopian scenario hit like a truck. Every death in Sunrise on the Reaping hits like a toy car, and it becomes harder to buy the sadness for how many times Haymitch has to hold dying people in his arms whom he couldn’t save. With little emotional buildup, Haymitch’s turn towards booze is rather inexplicable, as though it’s an achievement unlocked after watching so many friends and family die.

This should be a dark story, and yet it never reaches the depths it should, where the steps taken by Haymitch rarely feel like his own. Not only does it lack a psychological edge for its unfortunate protagonist, but it ends on a hopeful note, treating Haymitch’s descent into despair less like a sad conclusion and more like a breather before the next fight. This film is more content to get lost in its own Hunger Games allure and build needless backstories around the main Hunger Games characters. The pointless nature of such a prequel is laid bare by the premise, serving as a tedious bridge movie to a conclusion we’ve already witnessed. While other dystopian stories stressed the necessity and drive for revolution, Sunrise on the Reaping tells the audience to wait at the bar, get drunk, and wait for someone else to do it.